GIMP vs Pixelmator Pro
Detailed spec matrix, pricing differences, open-source status, and Reddit user consensus for macOS.
GIMP
FreeFree and open-source image editor for photo retouching, graphic design, and raster artwork
Pixelmator Pro
One-Time PurchaseProfessional image editing tools that anyone can use, built natively for Mac
Feature & Specification Matrix
| Specification | GIMP | Pixelmator Pro |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing Model | Free | One-Time Purchase |
| Open Source | Open Source (gitlab.gnome.org) | Proprietary |
| Architecture Support | Universal (Intel & M-Series) | Apple Silicon Native |
| Minimum macOS Version | macOS Big Sur 11 | macOS Monterey 12 |
| Category | Graphic Design | Photo Editing |
Which Should You Choose?
Choose GIMP if:
- You prefer a Free workflow for macOS.
- You value transparent, open-source code (hosted on gitlab.gnome.org).
- You want an application focused on free and open-source image editor for photo retouching, graphic design, and raster artwork.
Choose Pixelmator Pro if:
- You prefer a One-Time Purchase setup.
- You need features built around professional image editing tools that anyone can use, built natively for mac.
Community & Reddit Consensus
Curated user feedback from Reddit and tech communities.
GIMP User Opinions
“A Reddit user recommended GIMP as a free Photoshop alternative, noting that while 'the UI takes some getting used to,' the PhotoGIMP addon makes it feel much more familiar to Photoshop users.”
Reddit: Can anyone recommend a free Photoshop alternative?
“A user comparing Photoshop and GIMP said, 'Gimp is very capable,' adding that although Photoshop offers more features, many users may not actually need them.”
“A professional designer and photographer reported that they 'spend time equally on both Linux and macOS' and found modern GIMP capable enough for much of their workflow.”
“TechRadar concluded that GIMP provides 'pretty much everything seems to be there' in terms of editing tools, describing it as a viable free option for users on tight budgets.”
TechRadar: GIMP (2026) review
“Creative Bloq's evaluation found that GIMP can serve as 'a reasonable substitute' for some professional work, particularly considering its zero cost.”
Creative Bloq: GIMP vs Photoshop – Could you make the switch?
“The same Reddit recommendation cautioned that 'the UI takes some getting used to,' highlighting GIMP's learning curve for new users.”
“TechRadar criticized GIMP's canvas navigation, stating that scrolling around images with a trackpad was 'practically impossible' during testing.”
“The TechRadar reviewer also noted the absence of modern conveniences such as automated background removal tools found in competing editors.”
“A Reddit discussion criticizing comparisons with Photoshop argued that people often overlook 'features that GIMP lacks' when recommending it as a direct replacement.”
“Creative Bloq concluded that the more the reviewer relied on GIMP for professional deadlines, 'the more head-banging issues I have encountered.'”
Pixelmator Pro User Opinions
“Developers and designers on Product Hunt and Hacker News constantly praise it for being incredibly fast, native, and responsive, noting that its performance blows sluggish Electron-based design apps out of the water.”
Hacker News: Discussions on native Mac performance
“Users absolutely love the one-time payment model. Forums are filled with photographers who cite Pixelmator Pro as the primary reason they were finally able to cancel their expensive Adobe Creative Cloud subscriptions.”
“Photography enthusiasts on DPReview highlight the genuine utility of its Machine Learning tools. Features like the 'Magic Background Eraser' and 'Select Subject' are frequently cited as massive time-savers that accurately handle complex edges like hair and fur.”
DPReview: Community feedback on ML tools
“Following Apple's acquisition of Pixelmator in late 2024, there is noticeable anxiety in the community. Long-time users on Hacker News worry Apple might eventually strip the app for parts, merge it into Apple Photos, or abandon it entirely like they did with Aperture.”
“Power users note that while it is an excellent editor, it lacks some of the extreme high-end compositing features, deep typography controls, and advanced CMYK print tools found in full Adobe Photoshop.”
GetApp / User Reviews: Pixelmator Pro limitations
“Some users migrating from Photoshop find the UI paradigms and layer management slightly counterintuitive, noting that it takes time to unlearn decades of Adobe muscle memory.”
Frequently Asked Questions
How does the pricing of GIMP compare to Pixelmator Pro?
GIMP is available under a Free model, whereas Pixelmator Pro operates on a One-Time Purchase model.
Are GIMP or Pixelmator Pro open-source software?
GIMP is open source (available on gitlab.gnome.org), whereas Pixelmator Pro is a proprietary application.
Which app has better macOS & Apple Silicon compatibility?
GIMP supports Universal (Intel & M-Series) (minimum macOS Big Sur 11), while Pixelmator Pro supports Apple Silicon M-Series natively (minimum macOS Monterey 12).
What do Mac users on Reddit say about GIMP vs Pixelmator Pro?
On Reddit, users praise GIMP for "A Reddit user recommended GIMP as a free Photoshop alternative, noting that while 'the UI takes some getting used to,' the PhotoGIMP addon makes it feel much more familiar to Photoshop users.", while Pixelmator Pro is commended for "Developers and designers on Product Hunt and Hacker News constantly praise it for being incredibly fast, native, and responsive, noting that its performance blows sluggish Electron-based design apps out of the water.".
More Apps in Graphic Design
Krita
Free and open-source digital painting and illustration studio for artists, animators, and comic creators
Affinity by Canva
Professional vector design, photo editing, and desktop publishing in one free app — the successor to Affinity Designer
Inkscape
Free and open-source vector graphics editor for creating illustrations, icons, and SVG designs